A Sketched 151 Swirl Energy Set, and the Paperwork It Left Behind
A collector's hand-drawn five-swirl holo energy collection came back from grading with one card rejected and no written explanation. What the Reddit post documents, and what it does not.
The documented object here is a post. On 26 September 2026, a collector posting as u/aucapra published a photo set to r/pkmntcgcollections titled "Dream turned into reality, my sketched 5 swirl holo collection hand drawn by the talented artist Gamebox Tart". You can read the original post on r/pkmntcgcollections.
That post is the sole source for everything that follows. There is no accompanying statement from the artist, no grading company communication reproduced in the thread, and no invoice, submission number or certification number quoted. That is not a criticism of the collector, who wrote a clear and generous description of a personal project. It is the starting condition for anyone who wants to treat this collection as a record rather than a nice photograph — because in ten years, the photograph is what will survive, and the photograph does not carry provenance.
What the post establishes
Reduced to what is actually stated, the sequence runs like this.
- When 151 released, the collector set out to assemble every energy card showing five swirls in the holo layer.
- After completing that goal, they decided to commission a hand-drawn Pokemon on each card, with the condition that no swirl be covered.
- "Last year" they found the artist Gamebox Tart on Instagram and commissioned the work. Of the result, they write that he "blew all my expectations".
- After the cards came back, the collector says they learned the artist "had been recognized by PSA".
- The cards were submitted for grading in January and returned in July.
- PSA rejected the Mario and Luigi Pikachu sketch. The collector contacted a PSA representative through an intermediary and received no reply.
- Two cards were then sent to Ark Grading, an Australian company, and the collector says the resulting slabs look excellent.
Even this short list contains a discrepancy worth marking rather than smoothing over. The post describes a single rejection, then refers to sending "the 2 cards" to the second grader. Whether that means two separate sketches were rejected, or one rejected card was paired with another for the alternate submission, is not stated. Small inconsistencies like that are ordinary in a casual post and become load-bearing later, when someone tries to reconstruct which card went where.
Five swirls, and what a swirl is not
A swirl is a collector's term for a curved distortion visible in a card's holofoil layer, most often discussed on energy cards and other large flat foil areas where it is easy to see. It is a characteristic of how the foil sits on an individual card, which is why one card can show several and the next card off the same sheet can show none.
Three things follow from that, and all three matter for how this collection should be described.
First, there is no official designation for swirls. The Pokemon Company does not print them, catalogue them or assign a rarity to them. A "five swirl" card is a card a collector has counted swirls on, and the count depends on lighting, angle and where you decide one swirl ends.
Second, there is no published frequency. Nobody in this story claims one, and neither should anyone reporting on it. Any figure you see for how often a five-swirl energy appears is an estimate built from personal sorting, not a print statistic.
Third, the cards themselves are underspecified in the post. "151" is used without a language, set code, collector number or rarity line. The English Scarlet and Violet 151 release and the Japanese 151 release are separate products with separate printings, and holo energy cards from one are not interchangeable with the other for identification purposes. Anyone cataloguing this collection properly would need to record language, set, number and printing for each card before the swirl count means anything.
“if I had to guess it may have been a copyright conflict with Nintendo”
The rejection is a guess, not a ruling
The most quotable line in the post is the collector's own speculation about why the Mario and Luigi Pikachu sketch came back ungraded, and the collector flags it as speculation in the same sentence. That framing deserves to be preserved exactly as written, because it will not survive a second retelling. Posts like this get summarised into "PSA refuses sketches of Nintendo characters" within a week, and that sentence would be a fabrication.
What is on the record: one card was rejected, the collector asked for clarification through a middleman's PSA representative, and no answer came. What is not on the record: any statement from PSA, any published policy text, any rejection code, or any confirmation that copyright was the reason at all. Holo has not verified PSA's current position on artist-altered or sketched cards, and the post does not link to it. If that question matters to your own submission, read the grading company's own published submission terms before you send anything, and treat a forum summary as a lead rather than an answer.
The same discipline applies to the second grader. Ark Grading is named as an Australian company that slabbed the cards the collector was pleased with. That is a description of an outcome and an aesthetic judgment, not an endorsement, and it is worth repeating the general rule: a grade on a label is one company's opinion recorded on one day. Different companies apply different standards, and an altered card is not being assessed against the same expectations as a factory-fresh one.
Why the distinction matters after the post scrolls away
Altered cards sit awkwardly in every collecting vocabulary we have. Condition language assumes a factory object. Rarity language assumes a print run. Neither describes a card that one person deliberately drew on after purchase, and the value of such a card rests almost entirely on attribution — who made the mark, when, and on which specific card.
That is provenance, and provenance is only as durable as the documentation attached to it. A slab label can record a grade without recording the artist. A Reddit post can record the artist without surviving an account deletion. Collections of hand-altered cards from earlier eras routinely reach the secondary market with the alteration intact and the artist's name lost, and once lost, it is very rarely recovered. The useful moment to write it down is now, while the collector, the artist and the submission dates are all still available in one place.
One more separation worth stating outright: this is a display collection, not a play set. A card that has been drawn on is a different physical object from the printed card, and tournament rules about card condition and markings are set by Play! Pokemon documents that change over time and vary by region. Nothing in this post concerns sanctioned play, and nobody should infer legality either way from it.
Confidence note
Everything above rests on a single community post dated 26 September 2026 and the collector's own photographs. Holo has independently verified none of it: not the artist's identity or account, not the PSA submission or rejection, not the Ark Grading slabs, and not the swirl counts, which cannot be confirmed from photographs at all. The months given for submission and return are the collector's recollection, and no year is attached to them in the post. No prices, sales or valuations appear in the source, and none are reported here.
If the artist or either grading company wants to put a statement on the record, that would move several of these items from recollection into documentation, which is the only direction this kind of story ever improves in.
Sources
Reference links used for this piece. Confidence labels show how firmly each source is established.
- 1.Dream turned into reality, my sketched 5 swirl holo collection hand drawn by the talented artist Gamebox Tart
u/aucapra via r/pkmntcgcollections커뮤니티
Sole source for the collection, the commission, the January submission and July return, the PSA rejection of the Mario and Luigi Pikachu sketch, and the Ark Grading alternative. Quotes are taken verbatim from the post text. Photographs are the collector's.
당신의 생각
Does this sound like your scene?
하나를 눌러 보세요. 로그인도, 오답도 없어요.
이어서 읽기
Holo Magazine의 더 많은 이야기.

Japan's official channel shows a Kecleon card from Hadou Seeker, and leads with one question: what type is it?

Pokémon Club Is Reportedly Expanding Into Boys & Girls Clubs. The Details Are the Story.
