Card grading explained
Grading turns a card's condition into a comparable, third-party opinion — but it isn't free, fast, or always worth it. Here's how grading works across the major companies, and how to decide whether to send a card in at all.
Grading turns a card's condition into a comparable, third-party opinion — which is why graded cards trade more confidently sight-unseen. But grading isn't free, fast, or always worth it. Here's how it works across the major companies, and how to decide whether to send a card in at all.
What grading is
Card grading is a service where you send a raw card to an independent company. The grader examines it, gives an opinion on whether it's genuine, assigns a condition grade on a numeric scale, and seals it in a tamper-evident holder — the slab — with a label showing the card's details, a unique certification number, and the grade.
That does two useful things at once: it standardizes condition into a number buyers can compare, and it adds a third-party authenticity opinion. Both make a card easier to price and trade — but neither is a guarantee, and the grade is only ever an opinion.
Raw vs. graded
A raw card is ungraded — you judge its condition yourself from photos and description. A graded card carries an independent condition and authenticity opinion in a sealed holder. Each has trade-offs:
- Raw — cheaper, flexible, and you can inspect or re-sleeve it. The catch: condition is a judgment call, so trust rests on clear photos and an honest seller.
- Graded — easier to trade sight-unseen and protected in its slab, but it costs time and money to grade, and the holder can't be opened without breaking it.
“Grading doesn't change the card — it changes how confidently strangers can trade it.”
The major graders
A handful of companies dominate trading-card grading. They share the same basic idea but differ in scale, reputation by category, label style, and whether they break a grade into sub-scores. The big Western names:
Official site
- PSA — (Professional Sports Authenticator) — the largest grader by volume, with a deep, liquid resale market across many categories.
- BGS — (Beckett Grading Services) — known for sub-grades (centering, corners, edges, surface) and its top "Black Label" designation.
- CGC — (Certified Guaranty Company) — a major grader that has grown strongly in trading-card grading, including cards.
- SGC — long respected for vintage cards, with a distinctive slab.
Graders in Asia
Grading is global, and several graders are especially relevant in Asian markets — important if you collect Japanese or other regional cards. The landscape evolves, but you'll commonly encounter regional grading companies alongside the major Western names, sometimes with different slab styles and scales.
If you're buying a card graded by a company you don't recognize, do the same homework you'd do anywhere: look up the grader's official site, understand its scale, and verify the certification number against the grader's own lookup where one exists. A grade is only as meaningful as your confidence in who issued it.
Grading scales
Most graders use a numeric scale topping out at 10, with names attached to each tier (Gem Mint, Mint, Near Mint, and so on down). The shared intuition: 10 is essentially flawless to the eye; lower numbers reflect increasing wear. But the exact tolerances, half-grades, sub-grades, qualifiers, and "authentic but ungraded" outcomes differ by company.
PSA Grading 101
Because the fine print is each grader's to define — and can change — treat their official standards pages as the source of truth rather than memorizing a single chart. Ourarticle walks through one scale in depth as a worked example.
Is it worth grading?
Grading costs money and takes time, so it pays to be deliberate. A few honest questions to ask before you submit:
- Is the card valuable enough? — Grading fees can outweigh the benefit on lower-value cards. The math works best when a higher grade meaningfully changes how the card trades.
- Is the condition strong? — Grading rewards genuinely clean cards. A card with obvious flaws may come back at a grade that doesn't justify the cost.
- What's your goal? — Selling to strangers favors a widely trusted grader; documenting a personal collection may favor cost and speed.
- Do the current fees and turnaround fit? — These change often — always check the grader's official, current pricing.
Grades on Holo
marketplace
On Holo, a slab's grade is information that helps you compare listings — read it as a starting point, then look closely at the photos for centering, corners, edges, and surface, and check the card details against the label. Listing a graded card? State the grade and certification number exactly as printed, and add clear photos of the front, back, and label. Honest, legible listings are what Holo is built around. Start browsing in the.
Key takeaways
- Grading is a third-party condition + authenticity opinion in a sealed slab.
- PSA, BGS, CGC, and SGC lead in the West; regional graders matter in Asia.
- Scales top out at 10, but exact rules differ — trust official standards pages.
- Grade when value, condition, and goal align — and never expect a guaranteed grade.
Source notes & disclaimer
Each grading company defines and may update its own standards, scale, fees, and services. For anything authoritative, go to the primary sources:
Holo is an independent collectibles marketplace and is not affiliated with Nintendo, Game Freak, Creatures, The Pokémon Company, PSA, Beckett/BGS, CGC, SGC, eBay, TCGplayer, or any other third-party brand. Grades are third-party opinions, not Holo guarantees. Holo does not guarantee authenticity, grade, condition, value, liquidity, or future sale price, and implies no grader endorsement, partnership, or approval. Grading standards, fees, and turnaround are set by each company and subject to change; always confirm against their official pages.
Tu opinión
Would you send it to the graders?
Toca una. Sin registro, sin respuestas incorrectas.
Sigue leyendo
Más de Holo Magazine.

Japan's official channel shows a Kecleon card from Hadou Seeker, and leads with one question: what type is it?

Pokémon Club Is Reportedly Expanding Into Boys & Girls Clubs. The Details Are the Story.
