The 1st Edition Fossil hunt that ended with a cracked Dragonite slab
A collector on r/PokemonTCG says they spent about 30 months assembling a 1st Edition Fossil master set, finishing it by breaking a graded Dragonite out of its case. Here is what the post confirms, and what it doesn't.
What was actually posted
On 8 October 2026, a collector posting as u/weeble182 put up a photo thread on r/PokemonTCG titled 1st Edition Fossil Hunt - COMPLETED. The write-up is short and unusually specific for a collection post: a project started in 2024, aimed at a Fossil master set they never finished as a kid, deliberately narrowed to 1st Edition printings to make it "harder (and more expensive)".
The post says the hunt ran about 30 months and ended at 63 cards, with the final gap closed by cracking a Dragonite out of a graded slab. Cards came mostly from eBay and Cardmarket, bought slowly — the collector describes "biding my time to pick up great deals on HP cards that I felt were good binder copies", which is a condition decision as much as a budget one. Heavily played copies fill a binder page; they are not the same object as a high-grade copy, and the post never pretends otherwise.
A near-identical post went up on r/pkmntcgcollections the same week. The two read as the same collector and the same collection.
“no one wants the old stuff”
The spreadsheet, and what it does and does not show
The detail that got the thread moving is the spreadsheet. Excluding shipping, u/weeble182 puts the total at £1,022, with £756 of that spent on the holo cards alone. The two priciest buys are listed as Gengar at £175 and Dragonite at £150; the cheapest is an Ekans at 20p.
The post also logs the wins that make vintage sourcing feel like a sport. Listings that failed to mention a card was 1st Edition were, in the collector's framing, "a win" — a Hypno at £16 and a non-prerelease Aerodactyl at £20 are named as the best of them. And then the 2024 card show vendor who sold a mint holo Ditto for £25 with the line quoted above.
Treat all of this as what it is: one collector's self-reported purchase prices in GBP, paid across roughly 30 months on eBay, Cardmarket and at least one in-person table. They are not dated market data, they have not been checked against completed sales, and a price paid in 2024 tells you nothing about what the same card is listed or sold for today. The collector's own reference to "several price spikes" during the hunt is a reminder that the numbers in that spreadsheet are a timeline, not a price guide.
Sixty-three cards, and the argument about what counts
"Master set" is one of those collector terms that means something slightly different in every binder. For some people it is every card in the numbered set. For others it adds every variant: reverse printings, error runs, stamped promos tied to the release.
The English Fossil expansion is commonly catalogued as 62 cards. The post says 63. The write-up does not spell out what the extra card is, and the mention of a "non-prerelease" Aerodactyl implies the collector is tracking at least one variant distinction. Rather than guess, that is worth naming as an open question — the definition is the collector's to state, and until they do, the 63 is their count, not a catalogue count.
That ambiguity is not a flaw in the post. It is the actual subject. Two people can both say "Fossil master set, 1st Edition" and be describing different stacks of cardboard.
Why crack the Dragonite
Breaking a graded card out of its case to finish a raw binder set is a choice that reliably splits a comments section, and it is the part of this post most likely to be argued with. The practical logic is simple enough: if the set lives in pages, a slab does not fit the page.
The post does not say which grading company's holder it was, what grade was on the label, or why that particular copy was the one available. All three matter for anyone reading this as a model for their own hunt. A grading label is one company's opinion recorded on one day; removing the card does not change the cardboard, but it does remove the chain of custody that label represented. Whether that trade is worth it depends entirely on what the collection is for — and this one is clearly for looking at.
Where to read it first
The original thread, with the collector's own photographs, is on r/PokemonTCG, posted 8 October 2026 by u/weeble182. The cross-post sits on r/pkmntcgcollections.
Holo Magazine has not spoken to the collector, and the unresolved details — the 63rd card, the slab, the grading company — are theirs to answer. If they do, that is the follow-up.
Sources
Reference links used for this piece. Confidence labels show how firmly each source is established.
- 1.1st Edition Fossil Hunt - COMPLETED
r/PokemonTCG (Reddit), u/weeble182Community
Primary source: all prices, timeline, card counts and the vendor quote come from this post. Self-reported, unverified.
- 2.1st Edition Fossil Hunt - COMPLETED (cross-post)
r/pkmntcgcollections (Reddit)Community
Cross-post cited in the commissioning brief as the source of the 'several price spikes' line. Same-author assumption still needs confirming.
Your take
Does this sound like your scene?
Tap one. No sign-in, no wrong answers.
Keep reading
More from Holo Magazine.

Japan's official channel shows a Kecleon card from Hadou Seeker, and leads with one question: what type is it?

Pokémon Club Is Reportedly Expanding Into Boys & Girls Clubs. The Details Are the Story.
